This was a research paper written in 1998.
Superman is not White. White as a race means persons
indigenous to Europe. Superman just looks White. However, because he appears
White, he is treated as White, and as someone, others of his adopted race can
admire. Superman is a comic book character, the first superhero, and an emblem
of American ideals. But he is not White or an American. Superman is an alien,
born on the planet Krypton. He is not a citizen by birth or naturalization. He
is an illegal alien of the lowest order, sneaking into the United States,
hiding among the populace, burdening our natural resources. Yet because
Superman appears White, he is attributed with traditional American values and
qualities. Blacks, in America, are so far removed from their roots that they
should be considered indigenous. They can profess no specific country nor do
they have ancestral lands to reclaim. Yet, Blacks, because of their appearance
are viewed as aliens in the United States with undesirable values, qualities,
and cultures. Children's entertainment is the genesis of many of the ideals and
self-images that are first introduced to the child. Ideals, the concepts of
right and wrong, moral values; and self-images, the images that determine how a
child sees themselves and their position in society, form early in a child's
emotional development. The United States garners much of its culture from
Western European sources. This culture embraces a color psychology that assigns
positive attributes to the color White and negative attributes to the color
Black.
Entertainment media when dealing
with Black characters give them negative emotional content. Comic books are
modern mythology. They once occupied the position of simple morality plays,
with clearly defined good guys and bad guys. However, they have become more sophisticated,
introducing elements of fine literature. Yet in their sophistication, there is
still a significant amount of puerile handling of issues and characters. Most
Black Superheroes are tokens, emotionally under developed, hollow stereotypes
with no individual personalities beyond their Blackness, created to show their
parent companies social awareness. Most Black Superheroes are tokens whose
purpose is to increase sales through their inclusion. More to the point, many
of the Black Superheroes possess inferior morals, values, and qualities. The
Black Experience in comic books reflects the fears, prejudices, and stereotypes
of the White publishers, writers, and artists.
Black Superheroes leapt into mainstream US
comics in 1966, when Marvel Comics introduced the Black Panther in Fantastic
Four Vol. 1, Issue Number 52(Lee/Kirby).
Comic book companies give pretense
to reflecting Black cultures and Black characters, but continue denigrating
Blacks in an insidious way. Rather than the outright denigration of Blacks,
they have created Black "heroes" with negative characteristics. The
largest US publishers of comic books are the Marvel Comics Group and DC Comics,
a subdivision of Warner Bros. Marvel Comics is the company that publishes
Spiderman and the Xmen. DC Comics is the company that publishes Superman and
Batman. These companies are the mainstream publishers of comic books, and thus
the measuring stick of Black inclusion and representation in the medium of
comic books. Most of the early Black Superheroes were created to show the
increased social awareness of their publishers on racial issues.
Most
early Black Superheroes fought the Klan, the symbol of racism. The Black
Superheroes have had their bodies tied to burning crosses or have been whipped
or beaten by red-necked racists. Comic books dramatize and denounce overt acts
of racism. Yet the companies practice veiled racism. "I sent in pages of
art for Swamp Thing [a book detailing the adventures of a muck monster in the
swamps of Louisiana] and the editor called me back to say the pages needed
corrections. I had drawn Black characters. I figured since the action was
taking place in Louisiana that there should be Black characters in the book,
but he told me unless specifically requested all characters should be
White." The editors are the persons who determine the direction of a comic
book. If they have a bigoted attitude toward characters in their books, then
the books will reflect these attitudes. At the Wonder Con Comic book Convention
1992 in Oakland California, an editor expressed his admiration for one of the
writers working for his company, "That wop [Tony Isabella, a freelance
comic book writer] sure can write Black!". Isabella, at the time, was
writing the new Black Lightning series. With this type of enlightened
leadership, is there any wonder that Black Superheroes at best have been ill
conceived and at worst are an illustration of racial antipathy? The original
Captain America was created in 1941 Captain America #1(Simon/Kirby);
later he gained a teenage partner named Bucky. When Marvel comics recreated the
character for the Eighties they decided to update his partner as well. So
instead of the boy partner named Bucky, they decided that he should have a
Black man partner named Bucky. The writer could not understand why the Black
readership would be insulted. The white writer did not realize that calling a
Black man a buck alludes to the time when Blacks were Human chattel, and buck
was a term used to refer to the males.
The
reason that most Black Superheroes are ill conceived is that they are created
solely to boost sales in the culturally diverse marketplace. The characters are
politically correct window dressing. The real problem with this type of
tokenism is that the effort, sometimes, is so obvious. It is the square peg,
round hole, and hammer method of integration. Every team is composed of various
White members: Blond hair, Black hair, Red hair, male, female, different
cultures, different countries, and then there is the Black character. The Black
character is a shallow stereotype. The company guiltiest of this formulaic
creationism is DC Comics. Surprisingly, considering their positive record of
addressing social issues, the beginning of tokenism in comics can be traced to
Marvel Comics. Although it was not their intent to start this trend, it was the
outcome. Less enlightened creators and money hungry publishers saw this
tokenism as a way to increase their market share.
In
1975, Marvel Comics created The New Xmen; this was the first use of tokenism in
creating a team of characters. The New Xmen appeared in Giant size Xmen Summer
1975. They became the regular team in Uncanny Xmen #94, August 1975. The team
was an international group of superheroes: an American Indian, a Russian, a
German, a Canadian, an Irishman, and an African. Four White guys, an Indian guy
and a Black chick. The new Xmen were a sales success.
After the success the new Xmen had using tokenism--DC Comics followed suit. The
argument here is that DC added Black Superheroes to their rosters, but on close
examination, the creation of the new characters was frivolous and
opportunistic. The characters were created with no respect for the culture that
they represented. In other words, the characters were politically correct
fixtures, and DC Comics was adding Black Superheroes for cosmetic effect only.
For instance, in November 1976 DC Comics added Malcolm Duncan, a non-powered
teenager, to the roster of the Teen Titans. The Teen Titans were composed of
Robin, Batman's ward and junior partner. Aqualad, the friend and junior partner
of Aquaman, was a member of the team. Speedy, Green Arrow's long-suffering
assistant, was a member of the team as well. Wondergirl, a young orphan adopted
and given powers by Wonder Woman and her "sisters" on Paradise Island
joined the team. Kid Flash, the nephew of the Flash with similar powers,
rounded out the original membership. The irony of adding a Black Superhero to
the Teen Titans was that the team was composed of the junior partners of the
major heroes. However, since there were no major Black heroes it was an overt
act of colorization to add Mal, as he was known, to the team (Who's Who).
DC
Comics continued their ill-conceived creations with the introduction of Tempest
in September 1977. Tempest, Joshua Clay, was a member of the new Doom Patrol.
Most Black Superheroes have a touch of criminality; Joshua Clay was no
exception he, "gave in to the lure of the streets at an early
age"(Who's who). The character committed enough criminal acts to be forced
into military service in Viet Nam. During his tour of duty, he had repeated
"disciplinary problems" that resulted in his being demoted from medic
to foot soldier. After his in born super powers manifested, the ability to
generate energy blasts, he deserted the Army. To my knowledge, he is the only
military deserter in comics. After this auspicious origin, he slithered back to
the United States, assumed a false identity, and practiced medicine illegally.
The
most heavy-handed act of tokenism occurred in April 1976 when DC comics added a
Black Superhero to the Legion of Superheroes (Bates).
The
Legion of Superheroes is a team of super powered teenagers from many worlds one
thousand years in the future. The story detailing how Tyroc first met and
joined the Legion of Superheroes was to show that racism no longer existed in
the future. The Legion of Superheroes had, at the time, a twenty-one member
roster, seventeen of who were white-bread from the stars. Besides having super
powers, they were indistinguishable from regular White teenagers. The alien
looking members of the Legion of Superheroes included Braniac 5 a green-skinned
blond boy. Shadow Lass, a blue-skinned brunette. Timber Wolf, with vulpine
looking points added to his hair and blank eyes (who, coincidentally, had begun
to be drawn and act like Wolverine). Chameleon Boy had orange skin; large
pointed ears and small fleshy antennae.
Many of the defenders of DC Comics
actions make a number of arguments. There are several arguments surrounding the
addition of Tyroc to the Legion of Superheroes. The first is that they added a
Black Superhero. However, the Legion of Superheroes had been around since 1958
the first Black character didn't appear in the comic book until 1976. The
timeliness of the addition of the character is thus suspect. DC Comics was
conservative, not wanting to risk offending its readership. Marvel Comics
introduced the first Black Superhero in 1966, so DC Comics wouldn't have been
breaking new ground by introducing a Black Superhero in the Legion of Superheroes.
In answer to my detractors, I also want to point out that Star Trek first aired
on September 8,1966. It was written as 400 hundred years in the future with a
culturally diverse crew, so there were examples of future cultural diversity
that occurred in other media.
Later writers viewed Tyroc as a token; this
was never more obvious than in the tabloid-sized All New Collectors' Edition
C-55 1978, Superboy and the Legion of Superheroes, "The Millennium
Massacre". The cover read, "Featuring all 23 Legionnaires in a new
epic-length novel". Throughout the epic-length novel, one character was
singled out to guard the clubhouse Tyroc. Wildfire, then team leader ordered,
"Okay. Element Lad--you take Dream girl, Star boy and Tyroc, and guard head
quarters!" (19)
Later
in the issue the computer randomly chose a Legionnaire to stay behind on guard,
"Tyroc!! Seems like you came all the way from Marzal just to sit this one
out, pal!" Wildfire announced surprisingly (53).
Throughout
the whole issue, Tyroc neither spoke nor did anything significant.(Levitz)
Although Tyroc's creator Cary Bates had intended for Tyroc to be an active
well-used character, later writers turned him into politically correct window
dressing. Paul Levitz, at the time vice president of operations and freelance
writer, objected to the character. In the letter to the editor column, Legion
Outpost Paul Levitz answered an angry reader about his mishandling of the lone
Black character in a 22-character book. The reader wrote "...I read an interview
with Paul Levitz where he confessed his hatred for the Tyroc character,
supposedly because of the origin...Paul Levitz said that racial problems were a
"thing of the past"...[He] went on to say that he might use Tyroc
"only to kill him"(Goodwin). However, Paul Levitz did not defend his
dismissal and misuse of the character Tyroc.
Later
writers, Tom and Mary Bierbaum, brought the character back and he eventually
became President of the Earth.
However,
the most racially antipathetic character was published by Marvel comics. The
character was part of a duo of superheroes called Cloak and Dagger (Mantlo).
Cloak was a Black male teenage runaway "recruited to be a guinea pig for
the mob's experiment...using new synthetic drugs"(Marvel Universe). The drug
cursed the teen with a portal that connected him to a dimension of Blackness.
His billowing cloak defined the boundaries of this portal. The portal allowed
him to teleport himself, others, objects, and to swallow people. However, his
Blackness caused a hungering inside. His Blackness hungered for the light that
existed within all living creatures. Clearly stated Cloak could not live
without stealing the light from others.
Dagger
his counterpart was a blond White female teenage runaway in the same experiment
as Cloak. While Cloak was filled with a Blackness that sought to suck the life
from others, Dagger was given life affirming light powers. She was given the
grace of a ballerina, and increased inner light that she formed into daggers of
light. The ramifications of their characteristics and relationship were
problematic. First, there is the reflection of some of White societies' views
of Blacks as being frightening and a burden. Cloak survived only through
stealing the light from others and was a burden and a threat to Dagger. Cloak
was dependent on Dagger to supply a large portion of the light (whiteness) he
needed to survive; his Blackness constantly threatened to swallow her.
Secondly, Dagger reflected some of White societies' views of themselves. Dagger
had messianic tendencies--her whiteness purified junkies of drug addictions,
healed illnesses, and showed people the potential they could have achieved.
Lastly, there was a suggestive
sexual subtext to Cloak and Dagger's relationship. Cloak's hungering Blackness
could only be truly satisfied by Dagger's pure White light. The dialogue in
most of the books always spoke of Cloak's hunger for Dagger, and there was
always a White male character wanting to "break the hold" that Cloak
had on Dagger. For example Father Francis Xavier Delgado, "Oh Dagger, my
child--did it never occur to you that perhaps Cloak saved you in order to feed
off you?! Cloak you monster! Can't you see that you're killing her?!!"
(Mantlo). The subtext boils down to a Black man's unquenchable lust for a White
woman and how the White male must protect her.
Black
Superheroes are always shown as morally, intellectually, or heroically
inferior. One of the repetitive stereotypes that most Black Superheroes have is
criminality. They have participated in criminal or violent acts. Most Black
Superheroes have at their core a moral astigmatism; they are willing to act in
their own interest without regard to others. Storm, Ororo Monroe, of the Xmen
was a thief in Cairo, before setting herself up as a fertility goddess on the
plains of Africa. After being approached by Professor X, she leaves Africa to
return to America to join the Xmen, abandoning her worshipers to the elements
that she used to control for their benefit. (Encyclopedia of Superheroes)
Tempest,
Joshua Clay, of the Doom Patrol was a deserter from the military, former gang
member, and began practicing medicine under an assumed name. He never sought to
rectify his military status or to clarify his medical license. The original
Doom Patrol was a team composed of super powered misfits that had all been
helped by the scientific and surgical genius of Dr. Niles Caulder. The original
team had a racecar driver who had to have his brain placed in a robotic body
after a horrible accident (Who's who). A jet pilot whom after a radiation
accident while flying, developed transparent skin and was able to release an
energy being (Who's who). An actress who had inhaled "strange volcanic
gases" that caused her to grow and shrink uncontrollably. (Who's who). Super
powered outcasts that sought to protect a society that rejects them. The
original team was noble, with high aspirations.
Joshua Clay was created as a
criminal, then continued his criminal activities by practicing medicine under
an assumed name. Although he had studied enough medicine to pass the bar
"easily", he continued to be a character that seeks the easy way out
rather than deal with the responsibility for his actions.
Luke
Cage, was a former gang member, who escaped from prison. When he gained super
powers, he sought to profit from them. Spiderman and Batman suffered the loss
of loved ones to crime and sought to prevent others from suffering the same.
Superman had a well-established sense of right and wrong from his traditional Middle
American upbringing, Luke Cage's reason d'art was to make his super strength
profitable. "On one of his first nights in New York, he foiled a robbery
at a diner. When the owner gave him a cash reward. Cage became inspired to use
his superhuman strength for profit" (Marvel Universe). Further, he is
referred to as "streetwise and one of the angrier heroes"
(Encyclopedia of Superheroes). Mal Duncan, the non-powered Black teenager added
to the roster of the Teen Titans, met the Teen Titans when they helped him
defeat a street gang (Who's who).
Dagger was emotionally the
stronger character always admonishing Cloak to fight his self-righteous
self-centered ways. In New Mutants # 24 without his powers, Cloak is a
stammering stuttering malcontent. He only does the noble thing, reclaiming his
powers from one of the Professor's students, under pressure from Dagger and
Professor Xavier (Claremont).
Most
Black Superheroes are heroically inferior. The truest example of Black
Superheroes being written as inferiors heroically are the Black versions of
White heroes. The Black versions of White heroes are never as competent as the
counterpart White hero. In April 1975, DC Comics published Richard Dragon, Kung
fu fighter. The White lead character had a Black partner, Ben Turner, who
brainwashed became the Bronze Tiger. Richard Dragon was a thief that broke into
a private residence outside Kyoto Japan to steal. O-Sensei, the resident, saw
within the thief "a possible destiny of greatness." and invited him
to study Martial arts under his tutelage (Who's who). The Black character was a
student whose family had sent him to train from childhood with the teacher
O-Sensei. Richard Dragon studied fewer years, but achieved an equal level of
proficiency as the Bronze Tiger. Further, the Bronze Tiger had a less contrived
origin than the sense of possible greatness (Who's who). It is doubtful that a
martial arts teacher would take in a thief as a student, Eastern cultures are
less tolerant of thieves than Western cultures.
In 1971,
DC Comics created John Stewart, Green Lantern; he was created at a time when
the Green Lantern book was exploring social issues under the authorship of
Denny O' Neill. He became a replacement Green Lantern in case Hal Jordan, the
current Green Lantern, was unavailable. He was mostly forgotten for over a
decade before he became an active Green Lantern (Who's who).
John
Stewart should have remained forgotten. In the miniseries Cosmic Odyssey
(Starlin), a dupe was needed to add suspense to the series. Therefore, John
Stewart was added to the group of Superheroes trying to prevent the destruction
of the universe. In issue two of the miniseries, his over confidence and
arrogance caused the death of a Star and the destruction of two inhabited
planets. From beginning to end J'onn J'onzz, the Martian Manhunter flies around
out of character. The Martian Manhunter was a member of several incarnations of
the Justice League of America; he was quite familiar with the operations of a
Green Lantern's power ring. Yet throughout the issue, he played straight man
and admirer to the power of the ring.
The Martian Manhunter was a
member of several incarnations of the Justice League of America; he was quite
familiar with the operations of a Green Lantern's power ring. Yet throughout
the issue, he played straight man and admirer to the power of the ring. On page
6, John Stewart creates an "elixir" to cure an epidemic. Quote the
Martian Manhunter, "This is truly a marvelous device your ring." When
they ascertain the source of the threat, the Martian Manhunter wants to confront
it immediately, then it is John Stewart that advises caution (7).
The pair survives
a severe storm created by their foe; but their weapon, the anti-life catcher,
is destroyed. John Stewart shows foresight in having previously analyzed the
weapon and uses his ring to make a duplicate. Martian Manhunter finds the
working of the ring "Astounding"(21). Later the Martian Manhunter and
John Stewart switch roles, John Stewart becomes combative, and the Martian
Manhunter advises caution (28). Again, John Stewart shows foresight by
previously ordering his ring automatically to protect the Martian Manhunter
(30). Throughout the issue, he is insightful and cautious.
Suddenly on page 31
John Stewart changes totally, he leaves the Martian Manhunter in a protective
bubble and journeys the rest of the distance by himself to confront their foe.
The Green Lantern's power ring has one weakness it is ineffective against
anything yellow. The enemy is standing there with the doomsday bomb painted
yellow. I must digress for a moment, a benevolent race of blue-skinned immortal
aliens, the Guardians of the Galaxy, assigns sectors of space to be patrolled
by their emissaries, the Green Lantern Corps. A Green Lantern is trained in the
use of their ring before being given a power battery and accredited to patrol
their sector of space. The ring converts the bearer's thoughts into reality,
yet is ineffective against anything yellow. Every Green Lantern is trained for
such emergencies; the ring is capable of initiating "some very unusual
chemical reactions" (6)as John Stewart stated earlier. There are virtually
hundreds of ways around that limitation, the fun of the character was seeing
how a Green Lantern would resolve that limitation.
However, John Stewart just
stood there stunned. Hal Jordan, the original cosmic Green Lantern, would have
figured a way around the limitation against anything yellow, but cautious,
foresighted, creative John Stewart was suddenly too stupid to act.
In
the summer of 1982, the Legion of Superheroes added their second Black
character in their twenty-four year history, the new Invisible Kid. The new
Invisible Kid joined the Legion of Superheroes as the only member to speak
Interlac, the language of the future, with an accent. "Jacques is the only
black, French speaking superhero extant" (Encyclopedia of Superheroes,
p.151).
His predecessor was a teenage
genius named Lyle Norg, who developed a serum that turned him invisible. Lyle
led the team as leader for a number of adventures, the team has a democratic
leadership, and was a member of the Legion Espionage Squad.
The new Invisible
Kid was inconsistent, fearful, and unconfident. He just happened to be in the
wrong place at the right time. In seeking a cure for his sister, he brought her
to The Legion and Brainiac 5. He was given Lyle Norg's serum to help Brainiac
defeat Computo. Thereafter he joined the Legion, he was never shown to have any
skills or other contributions he could make to the team. Lyle was brave, an
excellent fighter, and a smart tactical leader. The only thing the new
Invisible Kid added was color.
In the letters to the editor column A. Goodwin
informed Paul Levitz "...When Black models are used in department store
catalogues, they like for them to present themselves as foreign because they
are more exotic and less offensive than us American Blacks." (Goodwin)
Paul Levitz went on to defend his creation of a French speaking Black character
as the only Legionnaire with an accent. "Jacques Foccart was introduced
not for the sake of his skin color [note: coincidentally The new Invisible Kid
was introduced in 1982 after Tyroc was written out of the book], but as a
hopefully interesting character, with a French accent because of his origin on
the Ivory Coast of Africa, where the French have taken great pains to help
their language live on. An "American Black" would speak Interlac
exactly as the other Legionnaires do, so the accent was added for an extra
touch..."(Goodwin)
The Black Superhero had arrived but
he was not welcome in the neighborhood. I only scratched the tip of the iceberg
with this paper. There is more material that I will only touch on in brief.
Cyborg, the Black member of the New Teen Titans, published November 1980, had
an IQ of 300, upper middle classed university research scientists for parents,
but still talked as if he was from the hood. My response was the same as the
Changeling's in Tales of the new Teen Titans #1, "You were a genius? What
happened, Vic? Take too many stupid pills?" (Wolfman) A Black female
character named Vixen; you know how those black women are (Who's who). Black characters
that had a reference to color or darkness in their names Sunspot, Black
Lightning, Black Goliath, the Black Racer, Black Panther, Vykin the Black,
Night Thrasher, Cloak, Bronze Tiger. Black characters that had names
representative of anger or violence: Tempest, Storm, Rage, Night Thrasher, War
Machine. Black characters with either a criminal record or criminal history or
criminal connections are too long a list. It is easier to name the ones
without: Black Panther, Vykin the Black, the Black Racer, and John Stewart, although
John Stewart could be charged with criminal negligence for the death of two
planets. The 1990's have seen a change in the market place; smaller companies
began publishing more culturally diverse titles. These companies had successful
runs with their titles, and are helping to change the image of the Black
superhero. Superman is not White, which is the reason we need more and better
black Superheroes in comic books. Whites have relatives in the stars, bright
wondrous futures, and the blood of nobility. Even the best Black Superheroes
are denizens of the ghetto, and all the Black Kryptonians died, "Vathlo
the island populated with Blacks" (Who's Who). Black children should look
at the stars and see themselves. Look at the future and see their part in it.
Look at their blood and see it as something valuable and magical. Look at comic
books and see someone much like themselves doing good because it is the right
thing to do.